This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats.
Read more about our affiliate linking policy.
This recipe for Beaver Tail Pie cookies was inspired by a recipe I had made for homemade cookies a couple of years ago and it just couldn’t keep up.
It was such a fun cookie to make, so I was so excited to try making it again, but it just didn’t work as well.
This time, I used a different recipe that had a much larger amount of butter.
It just worked, and it was so delicious.
I had been looking for a great recipe for buttery, soft, delicious buttery cookies that I could make in a few minutes, so the only thing that kept coming to mind was using a vanilla bean paste.
When I was preparing the recipe, I decided that the only way I would be able to achieve the right consistency was to use a bit of almond extract to help with the baking process.
I then thought about making a double batch of the cookies, so that I would have a double supply for when I needed them.
It turned out to be a perfect recipe for both cookies, with a couple extra ingredients added for flavor.
I had never tried vanilla bean extract before, so it was a little tricky to figure out how to do it right.
I decided to start by making some vanilla bean muffins, but I wanted to experiment with different ways to use it, and I was pleasantly surprised when I was able to make a nice batch of this recipe.
As with any good recipe, this one really gets you started.
I didn’t have the time to make everything perfectly, so if you need to skip the cookies for something else, this recipe will make them very quick and easy.
First, mix the almond extract in a bowl.
Then, add the melted butter to the almond mixture, and mix until smooth.
Next, add some sugar, cocoa, vanilla extract, and vanilla bean powder, and let it all combine together.
Finally, add a tablespoon of almond milk, vanilla, and a pinch of salt, and you are ready to go.
These cookies are a great way to introduce a new flavor to your cookie recipes.
The almond extract is so delicious and has a nice nutty taste, and the chocolatey vanilla bean flavor adds a nice balance to the cookie dough.
Now if you like a cookie that’s easy to make and tastes delicious, this is the cookie for you!
Recipe adapted from the Cook’s Illustrated Cookbook, a trademark of Penguin Group PLC